Our Team

Brian joined SFM in 1993 and is currently the fourth generation of leadership. His Finance degree from Xavier University and MBA from the University of Notre Dame allow him to assist his commercial clients in complex coverage solutions. He currently serves on the Clinton County Port Authority Board and is a member of Entrepreneur Organization and the Wilmington Rotary Club.

John joined SFM in 1988 and currently leads our personal lines and agriculture divisions. He creates personalized insurance solutions for individuals and families as well as advises agriculture clients in the coverage they need. He studied at The Ohio State University and currently serves on the Clinton County MRDD board.

Todd was the co-owner of Heskett Insurance and Weisenberger Insurance for many years. In 2024 he and his wife Mary decided to partner with SFM Insurance, focusing on exceptional service for their clients and leaving the day-to-day operations to SFM Insurance. According to Todd, he and Mary chose SFM insurance because of their shared values and ensuring that their clients will continue to receive the highest level of care. Todd is active in the Hillsboro community and on the Board of Directors of the Highland County Hospital Foundation.

Mary was the co-owner of Heskett Insurance and Weisenberger Insurance for many years. In 2024 she and her husband Todd, decided to partner with SFM Insurance, focusing on exceptional service for their clients and leaving the day-to-day operations to SFM Insurance. According to Mary, she and Todd chose SFM insurance because of their shared values and ensuring that their clients will continue to receive the highest level of care. Mary is very involved in the Hillsboro community, focusing her service on the Highland County Hospital Foundation.

Donna joined SFM in 2018, having over 20 years’ experience in the commercial insurance industry. Donna’s objective is to be a trusted advisor to our clients, assisting them with their coverage needs and building strong client focused relationships. She graduated college achieving a paralegal degree. She actively volunteers in the community for various causes.

Anessa joined SFM in 2010 and has over 20 years of experience in the insurance industry.  She works with SFM’s larger, more complex commercial clients, helping them with coverage selection and answering tough questions.  Anessa has earned the Certified Insurance Service Representative and Certified Professional Insurance Agent designations.  Anessa has started a non-profit “Igniting a Spark to Prevent Suicide, Inc.”, to provide education and support to communities, schools, organizations, and individuals.

Cindy joined SFM in 2015 as a Commercial Lines Account Manager. She has 10 years of insurance experience working for a national insurance carrier prior to coming to SFM. Cindy’s expertise ranges from smaller businesses to agribusiness. She focuses on customer relations and relationship building.

Kevin started at SFM in 2024 as a customer support agent. Before joining SFM, he worked for an international insurance company for ten years. He focuses on the company’s back-office operations.

Sherry has been with SFM since 1993. As the lead Personal Lines Account Manager, Sherry’s dedication to her insurance career has motivated her to earn her CPSR, CPIA and CISR designations. Her clients experience this level of commitment with each coverage conversation. Sherry also is active in the Chillicothe youth bowling leagues.

Kathy is a Personal Lines Account Manager new to SFM in 2017. She graduated from Wilmington College with a Bachelor’s degree in Communications & English. Kathy is excited to join our team and brings with her over 20 years of customer care experience.

Kelly is a Personal Lines Account Manager who joined SFM insurance in 2025 when Weisenberger Insurance was acquired. Kelly has worked in insurance since 2013. Kelly truly enjoys connecting with her clients and meeting their unique needs and thrives on the challenge the insurance industry provides. In her time away from the office Kelly is passionate about saving cats.

Stephanie is excited to join the SFM team in 2024 and brings with her five years of experience in the insurance industry.
She is a graduate of Sinclair Community College, where she was a member of Phi Theta Kappa and National Society of Leadership and Success honor societies.
Stephanie serves as Secretary of The Friends of the Wilmington Public Library organization and Assistant Secretary of the CWM Board at First Christian Church (Disciples of Christ).
She is an active member of her church and volunteers at many events throughout the community.

Carolyn joined SFM in 2007 as our Claims Manager. She works tirelessly as a liaison between our carriers and our clients to satisfactorily resolve claims issues. In addition to her claims responsibilities, she manages SFM’s IT and communications infrastructure.

Julie came to work at SFM in 1997 as our Controller. She handles the accounting, human resources, IT and building maintenance for all of our corporate offices. Julie is a past board member of the Greater Wilmington Human Resource Association and the Clinton County Leadership Institute. She is a graduate of Wright State University.

Brittany joined SFM in 2022 as our administrative assistant.  She manages the phones for the organization and the walk-in traffic in our Wilmington office while assisting accounting and sales.  She is a devoted wife and mother of four.  She is a graduate of Laurel Oaks CDC where she completed a two-year business management program and was a National Honor Society member.  She has an associates degree from Purdue Global University where she is also a member of the National Honor Society of Collegiate Scholars.