Service Center - SFM Insurance

Need to file a claim or make a payment? To file a claim online or make a direct bill payment, click on your carrier’s link, below, to be taken directly to their website. Have a question about filing a claim or about the status of an existing claim? Click here for a full list of our locations and contact information. Our team of seasoned experts are here to work with you from beginning to end, day or night. For all other insurance questions or needs, please email us at [email protected] or contact us at the location closest to you.

For immediate assistance, day or night, call 937-382-2546 or click here to access SFM’s customer InsurLink (formerly Client Portal).

Acuity Insurance

To report a claim:

Call 800-242-7666 (available 24/7)

To make a payment online:

Call 800-242-7666

American Modern Insurance Group

To report a claim:

Call 800-375-2075 (available 24/7)

To make a payment online:

Call 800-543-2644

Berkshire Hathaway Homestate Companies

To report a claim:

To make a payment online:

Celina Insurance

To report a claim:

www2.celinainsurance.com

Call 800-231-2318 (available 24/7)

To make a payment online:

www2.celinainsurance.com

Central Mutual Insurance

To report a claim:

(client sign-on is required)

www.central-insurance.com

Call 888-263-2924 (available 24/7)

To make a payment online:

(client sign-on is required)

www.central-insurance.com

Cincinnati Insurance

To report a claim:

(Online claim reporting not available)

Call 877-242-2544 (available 24/7)

To make a payment online:

Foremost Insurance

To report a claim:

www.foremost.com

To make a payment online:

www.foremost.com

Grange Insurance

To report a claim:

(client sign-on is required)

www.grangeinsurance.com

Call 800-445-3030 (available 24/7)

To make a payment online:

(client PIN# is required)

www.grangeinsurance.com

Hagerty Insurance

To report a claim:

(ext. 5)

www.hagerty.com

Call 800-922-4050

To make a payment online:

www.hagerty.com

Call 800-888-220-9565

Liberty Mutual Insurance

To report a claim:

www.libertymutualgroup.com

Call 800-362-0000 (available 24/7)

To make a payment online:

www.libertymutualgroup.com

Call 866-290-2920

Philadelphia Insurance

To report a claim:

To make a payment online:

Progressive Insurance

To report a claim:

(client sign-on is required)

www.progressiveagent.com

Call 800-274-4499 (available 24/7)

To make a payment online:

www.progressiveagent.com

Safeco Insurance

To report a claim:

(online claim reporting not available)

Call 800-332-3226 (available 24/7)

To make a payment online:

(client sign-on is required)

Travelers Insurance

To report a claim:

www.travelers.com

Call 800-238-6225

To make a payment online:

(client sign-on is required)

www.travelers.com

UFG Insurance

To report a claim:

www.ufginsurance.com

Call 800-343-9131

To make a payment online:

www.ufginsurance.com

Call 800-637-6309

West Bend Insurance Company

To report a claim:

(online claim reporting not available)

www.thesilverlining.com

Call 877-922-5246 (available 24/7)

To make a payment online:

www.thesilverlining.com

Page 1 of 0